MAY 31 2026 | By Steven Wieting & David Bailin

When Silver is as Valuable as Gold:  Trimming Hardware Overweights in US, Asia

Download PDF

When Silver is as Valuable as Gold:  Trimming Hardware Overweights in US, Asia

In 1925, President Calvin Coolidge famously said “the chief business of the American people is business.” Today, we would add “the chief business of the US is technology.”

The S&P Information Technology Sector has returned about 2.6X more than the next strongest sector since 1990 (Figure 1). Healthcare is the only other sector to beat the overall S&P.

The S&P 500 is being powered by its 38% IT-sector weighting which excludes tech companies in Communication Services and Discretionary. With the rapid growth in AI infrastructure spending, we believe the Industrials and Utilities sectors have also become part of the IT boom. While there are some strongly tech-driven markets in Asia such as South Korea and Taiwan, the overall weighting of tech in the US is two to three times that of non-US markets.

Figure 1 - S&P Economic Sectors and Returns Since Sep. 1989 Inception
EP33_fig1
Source: CIO Group, Haver Analytics. Note: Real Estate return is 20 year history.

Beware When Valuations Anticipate Endless Earnings Boom

The IT sector trades at a trailing valuation that is 43% higher than the S&P 500. EPS for information technology is expected to be up 50.1% this year compared to “just” 13.9% for other sectors. This would explain and close that gap. The 50% EPS gain for 2026 could also be an understatement. Business investment in computing power for AI data centers is in its third consecutive boom year, with public hyperscaler spending projected at a 70% pace (Figure 2). As a result, semiconductor profits are expected to more than double.

Figure 2 - S&P Semiconductor Index and US Business Investment in Computers Y/Y%
EP33_fig2
Source: CIO Group, Haver Analytics

A Bit of DRAM History – Higher Highs and Lower Lows

In an age of “meme stocks” and “meme coins,” you cannot blame investors for chasing real corporate profits. If stocks are going up fast and for fundamental reasons, all the better. However, the latest phase of this tech rally is particularly risky.

The strongest component of the tech rally now is memory chips. DRAM pricing is up 5-fold on chip shortages. Memory chip makers will be “sold out” of their product and boosting production as rapidly as possible to meet demand in the coming year or two. There is no doubt their profits will surge as data center builders and others are willing to pay more for “chips now” to complete their projects quickly. But the business of AI providers is to sell their data services, not expand their stock of hardware.

Looking back on the history of DRAM pricing, there has never been a time when profits margins expanded and remain high without setback. As figure 3 shows, DRAM is a commodity and its scarcity is temporary. Prices have risen and fallen every other year. This will prove true eventually even as there will be massive future maintenance spending on the now larger capital stock of data centers.

Figure 3 – Commodities Both: DRAM Wholesale Price vs Crude Oil
EP33_fig3
Source: CIO Group, Haver Analytics

DRAM: Earning All of Nvidia’s AI Returns in Just One Year

The shortage of memory and other hardware components has meant that DRAM leaders such as Micron of the US and SK Hynix of South Korea have achieved stock market returns in the past year roughly equal to those of Nvidia’s over the last three years. This takes us back to when OpenAI convinced the world that AI would be a breakthrough that changes life as we know it.

Nvidia’s innovations in chip design have enabled AI more than any other company. It has the greatest revenue exposure to AI, even if it is no longer unique in providing this IP. There are many new advanced chips and chip designs coming to market that will, over time, create price competition for high end chips.

But for markets to provide returns for commodity memory in the same fashion as Nvidia seems unsustainable to us. While computer equipment components are far more consequential in the age of AI, we look at the DRAM maker “catch up” trade as akin to “silver catching up with gold.” Silver is the more ubiquitous, more volatile commodity. Yet, investors sometimes push it to dramatically higher returns than gold before an inevitable decline sets in (See figure 4).

Figure 4 – Nvidia, Micron and SK Hynix Shares Rebased June 2021 = 100
EP33_fig4a
Figure 4 – Gold vs Silver Rebased June 2021 = 100
EP33_fig4b
Source: CIO Group, Haver Analytics

We Are Trimming Hardware Overweights in US, Asia

As we’ve noted previously, the outperformance of all tech hardware has exceeded software by the greatest amount since 2000, when the advent of the internet drove an unsustainable boom in telecom equipment spending. This month, semiconductors exceeded systems software returns by the greatest margin since 2000 (Figure 5).

Software makers face an onslaught of competition from AI services who want to win customers solving the same problems. Yet, the valued service they all provide is code, the solutions we pay for. Hardware is simply the vehicle that enables it.

Hardware innovation will always be a value to us embodied in firms such as Apple and Nvidia. But with the latest powerful surge in storage and components, we’ve decided to trim tech hardware weightings in both the US and Asia. We’ve reinvested the majority of the proceeds in dividend growth strategies in both the US and abroad for the time being.

Our CIO Group portfolios remain slightly overweight US tech hardware and more definitively overweight software, particularly cybersecurity. The profit gains of hardware makers are a fundamental driver of today’s outperformance. We see no evidence that AI infrastructure spending is falling or necessarily will fall in the coming year. Yet the fact is, hardware spending at the current pace is far too rapid to sustain for many more years (please see our Point of May 10). And with such tremendous tech exposure in the US equity market, we will need to be ready for the day when fundamentals don’t support immediate gains, even if we are long-term bulls.

Figure 5 – Performance Divergence Most Extreme Since 2000System Software Less Semiconductors 12-Month % Changes
EP33_fig5
Source: CIO Group, Haver Analytics

History Bears Remembering

Calvin Coolidge was president during the roaring 20s, leaving office in early 1929 before the October crash and onset of the Great Depression. The Depression was a painful but passing phase in the great march of progress. Even so, there were many signs indicating that a crash was possible, then likely.

The larger macroeconomic mistakes of the Roaring 20s and Great Depression need not be repeated. But here is today’s minor parallel. We see markets as building major concentrated risk in hardware and in particular tech hardware commodities. It may not come soon, but an inevitable revaluation of these sectors is ahead. As always, we want to be cognizant of the risks and be prepared for appropriate portfolio actions (Figure 6).

Figure 6 – How to Hedge with Asset Allocation - Assets and Sectors with Low or Negative Short-term Correlation to Tech
EP33_fig6
Source: CIO Group, Bloomberg, Haver Analytics
Source: Haver Analytics CIO Capital Group LLC is an SEC-registered investment adviser. This material is for informational purposes only and does not constitute investment advice or recommendations. All investing involves risk, including potential loss of principal. Forward-looking statements involve risks and uncertainties that could cause actual results to differ materially. Past performance is not indicative of future results. For additional information about CIO Capital Group LLC, see our Form ADV Part 2A at www.adviserinfo.sec.gov.